top 10 dfm problems that affect every design

1. Incorrect tolerances

Tolerances are the acceptable range of variation in a part’s dimensions. Incorrect tolerances can lead to parts that don’t fit together properly or function as intended. This can result in assembly issues, performance problems, and increased scrap rates.

To avoid tolerance issues, designers should:

Understand the manufacturing processes and their capabilities
Specify tolerances that are appropriate for the manufacturing process and material
Use geometric dimensioning and tolerancing (GD&T) to clearly communicate the design intent
Collaborate with manufacturing engineers to ensure the tolerances are achievable and cost-effective

Request PCB Manufacturing & Assembly Quote Now

2. Inadequate draft angles

Draft angles are the tapers added to the sides of a part to allow it to be easily removed from a mold or die. Inadequate draft angles can cause parts to stick in the mold, leading to damage, increased cycle times, and higher manufacturing costs.

To ensure adequate draft angles, designers should:

Understand the manufacturing process and the minimum draft angles required
Add draft angles to all vertical surfaces, including ribs, bosses, and holes
Use a minimum draft angle of 1° for most materials, and increase the angle for softer or stickier materials
Avoid using zero draft angles unless absolutely necessary

3. Improper wall thickness

Wall thickness refers to the thickness of the walls in a part. Improper wall thickness can lead to a variety of problems, including:

Sink marks or voids in thick sections
Warping or distortion in thin sections
Increased cycle times and material costs
Difficulty filling the mold cavity

To optimize wall thickness, designers should:

Use a consistent wall thickness throughout the part
Avoid thick sections that can cause sink marks or voids
Use ribs or gussets to reinforce thin sections
Follow the recommended wall thickness guidelines for the material and manufacturing process

Material	Minimum Wall Thickness
ABS	1.0 mm
Polypropylene	0.75 mm
Polycarbonate	1.0 mm
Nylon	0.8 mm

4. Poor gate and ejector pin placement

Gates and ejector pins are used to inject molten plastic into the mold cavity and eject the finished part from the mold. Poor placement of gates and ejector pins can cause a variety of problems, including:

Visible gate marks or ejector pin marks on the part surface
Warping or distortion due to uneven cooling
Difficulty filling the mold cavity
Increased cycle times and scrap rates

To optimize gate and ejector pin placement, designers should:

Place gates and ejector pins in non-critical areas of the part
Use multiple gates for large or complex parts to ensure even filling and cooling
Avoid placing gates or ejector pins near thin sections or stress concentration areas
Collaborate with manufacturing engineers to determine the best locations for gates and ejector pins

5. Undercuts and snap fits

Undercuts are features that prevent a part from being easily removed from a mold, such as holes or slots that are perpendicular to the direction of mold opening. Snap fits are features that allow two parts to be snapped together without the need for fasteners or adhesives. Both undercuts and snap fits can be challenging to manufacture and can lead to increased costs and quality issues.

To avoid undercut and snap fit issues, designers should:

Minimize the use of undercuts and snap fits whenever possible
Use side-action cams or slides to create undercuts in the mold
Design snap fits with sufficient clearance and draft angles to allow for easy assembly and disassembly
Use finite element analysis (FEA) to simulate the behavior of snap fits and ensure they will function as intended

6. Insufficient clearance for assembly

Clearance refers to the space between two mating parts that allows for easy assembly and disassembly. Insufficient clearance can lead to interference fits, which can cause parts to become stuck or damaged during assembly.

To ensure sufficient clearance for assembly, designers should:

Understand the manufacturing processes and their tolerances
Use a minimum clearance of 0.1 mm for most materials and processes
Increase the clearance for larger parts or tighter tolerances
Use 3D tolerance stackup analysis to ensure the clearances are adequate throughout the assembly

7. Unoptimized part orientation

Part orientation refers to the way a part is positioned in the mold or on the build platform during manufacturing. Unoptimized part orientation can lead to a variety of problems, including:

Increased support material usage and post-processing time for 3D printed parts
Warping or distortion due to uneven cooling in injection molded parts
Difficulty filling the mold cavity or achieving uniform wall thickness

To optimize part orientation, designers should:

Orient the part to minimize the amount of support material needed for 3D printing
Orient the part to allow for easy ejection from the mold and minimize warping in injection molding
Consider the flow of molten material and the location of gates and cooling channels
Use simulation software to analyze the effects of part orientation on manufacturability and performance

8. Improper material selection

Material selection is a critical aspect of DFM that can have a significant impact on the manufacturability, performance, and cost of a part. Improper material selection can lead to a variety of problems, including:

Difficulty processing the material due to its viscosity, shrinkage, or other properties
Poor mechanical properties or dimensional stability
Incompatibility with the intended use environment or regulations
Higher material and processing costs

To select the proper material, designers should:

Understand the requirements and constraints of the application, such as strength, stiffness, temperature resistance, and chemical resistance
Consider the manufacturing process and its capabilities, such as the maximum achievable tolerances and surface finishes
Use material property databases and supplier recommendations to identify suitable materials
Conduct testing and prototyping to validate the material selection and performance

9. Lack of standardization

Standardization refers to the use of common parts, materials, and processes across a product family or organization. Lack of standardization can lead to increased complexity, higher costs, and longer lead times.

To improve standardization, designers should:

Use off-the-shelf components whenever possible, such as fasteners, bearings, and connectors
Develop a library of standard parts and features that can be reused across multiple designs
Collaborate with suppliers to identify commonly available materials and processes
Use modular design principles to create interchangeable subassemblies and components

10. Inadequate communication

Effective communication between designers, engineers, and manufacturers is essential for successful DFM. Inadequate communication can lead to misunderstandings, errors, and delays that can impact the quality, cost, and time-to-market of a product.

To improve communication, designers should:

Use clear and concise documentation, such as 3D models, drawings, and specifications
Collaborate with manufacturing engineers early in the design process to identify potential issues and opportunities for improvement
Use design reviews and feedback loops to ensure that all stakeholders are aligned and informed
Establish a culture of open communication and continuous improvement within the organization

FAQ

1. What is Design for Manufacturing (DFM)?

Design for Manufacturing (DFM) is a methodology that focuses on designing products that are easy to manufacture, assemble, and test. The goal of DFM is to reduce costs, improve quality, and accelerate time-to-market by optimizing the design for the manufacturing process.

2. Why is DFM important?

DFM is important because it can have a significant impact on the success of a product. By designing for manufacturability, companies can:

Reduce manufacturing costs and lead times
Improve product quality and reliability
Increase production efficiency and capacity
Accelerate time-to-market and customer satisfaction

3. What are some common DFM issues?

Some common DFM issues include:

Incorrect tolerances
Inadequate draft angles
Improper wall thickness
Poor gate and ejector pin placement
Undercuts and snap fits
Insufficient clearance for assembly
Unoptimized part orientation
Improper material selection
Lack of standardization
Inadequate communication

4. How can designers avoid DFM issues?

Designers can avoid DFM issues by:

Collaborating with manufacturing engineers early in the design process
Using DFM guidelines and best practices for the specific manufacturing process and material
Conducting design reviews and simulations to identify potential issues
Using standardized parts and materials whenever possible
Communicating clearly and effectively with all stakeholders

5. What are the benefits of implementing DFM in product development?

The benefits of implementing DFM in product development include:

Lower manufacturing costs and higher margins
Faster time-to-market and increased competitiveness
Improved product quality and customer satisfaction
Reduced waste and environmental impact
Enhanced collaboration and innovation within the organization

Conclusion

Design for Manufacturing (DFM) is a critical aspect of product development that can have a significant impact on the success of a product. By understanding and addressing the top 10 DFM problems that affect every design, designers and engineers can create products that are easier to manufacture, assemble, and test, resulting in lower costs, higher quality, and faster time-to-market.

To overcome these challenges, designers should collaborate closely with manufacturing engineers, use DFM guidelines and best practices, conduct thorough design reviews and simulations, and communicate effectively with all stakeholders. By implementing DFM principles and continuously improving their designs, companies can gain a competitive advantage and deliver innovative, high-quality products to their customers.