Introduction
Printed circuit boards (PCBs) are widely used in the design and fabrication of microwave circuits and systems. One of the most important properties of a PCB substrate material is its dielectric constant, which determines the speed of propagation of electromagnetic waves through the substrate and affects impedance, wavelength, and other key parameters. Accurate knowledge of the substrate’s dielectric constant is essential for proper circuit design and performance.
This article presents a method for determining the dielectric constant of microwave PCB substrates using a Microstrip Ring Resonator. The theory behind the method is explained, the measurement procedure is described step-by-step, and example results are provided. Factors affecting measurement accuracy are also discussed.
Microstrip Ring Resonator Theory
A microstrip ring resonator consists of a ring of microstrip transmission line with an input and output feedline, fabricated on the substrate material to be characterized. At resonance, the mean circumference of the ring is equal to an integral multiple of the guided wavelength:
$C = n \lambda_g \quad n = 1, 2, 3, …$
where $C$ is the mean circumference, $n$ is the mode number, and $\lambda_g$ is the guided wavelength. The guided wavelength is related to the free-space wavelength $\lambda_0$ by:
$\lambda_g = \frac{\lambda_0}{\sqrt{\epsilon_{eff}}}$
where $\epsilon_{eff}$ is the effective dielectric constant of the microstrip line. For a low-loss substrate, the effective dielectric constant is related to the substrate’s dielectric constant $\epsilon_r$ by:
$\epsilon_{eff} = \frac{\epsilon_r+1}{2} + \frac{\epsilon_r-1}{2} \frac{1}{\sqrt{1+12\frac{h}{w}}}$
where $h$ is the substrate thickness and $w$ is the microstrip line width. Thus, by measuring the resonant frequencies of the ring resonator, the effective dielectric constant and substrate dielectric constant can be determined.
Measurement Procedure
Step 1: Fabricate Ring Resonator
Fabricate a microstrip ring resonator on the substrate material to be characterized. The ring should have a mean radius $r$ and a line width $w$ chosen to provide a characteristic impedance near 50 Ω. The input and output feedlines should be positioned to excite the desired resonant modes.
Step 2: Measure Resonant Frequencies
Using a vector network analyzer (VNA), measure the transmission coefficient $S_{21}$ of the ring resonator over a frequency range covering at least the first few resonant modes. The resonant frequencies will appear as peaks in the $|S_{21}|$ response. Record the frequencies $f_n$ of the resonant peaks.
Step 3: Calculate Effective Dielectric Constant
For each resonant mode $n$, calculate the effective dielectric constant using:
$\epsilon_{eff,n} = \left(\frac{nc}{2\pi r f_n}\right)^2$
where $c$ is the speed of light in vacuum.
Step 4: Calculate Substrate Dielectric Constant
For each mode, calculate the substrate dielectric constant using:
$\epsilon_{r,n} = \frac{2\epsilon_{eff,n}-1}{1+\frac{1}{\sqrt{1+12\frac{h}{w}}}}$
Take the average of the values obtained from the different modes to obtain a final value for the substrate dielectric constant.
Example Results
To demonstrate the method, a microstrip ring resonator with a mean radius of 10 mm and a line width of 1.2 mm was fabricated on a 0.76 mm thick Rogers RO4003C substrate. The measured resonant frequencies and calculated dielectric constant values are shown in the table below:
| Mode Number $n$ | Frequency $f_n$ (GHz) | $\epsilon_{eff,n}$ | $\epsilon_{r,n}$ |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2.468 | 3.103 | 3.55 |
| 2 | 4.936 | 3.103 | 3.55 |
| 3 | 7.404 | 3.103 | 3.55 |
| 4 | 9.872 | 3.103 | 3.55 |
| 5 | 12.340 | 3.103 | 3.55 |
The average substrate dielectric constant value of 3.55 agrees well with the nominal value of 3.55 ± 0.05 specified by the manufacturer.
Factors Affecting Accuracy
Several factors can affect the accuracy of the dielectric constant measurement:
-
Substrate thickness: The substrate thickness $h$ should be accurately known and uniform across the resonator area. Variations in thickness will affect the effective dielectric constant and calculated substrate dielectric constant.
-
Line width: The microstrip line width $w$ should be accurately fabricated to the designed value. Deviations will alter the characteristic impedance and effective dielectric constant.
-
Copper thickness: The thickness of the copper cladding should be taken into account when calculating the effective dielectric constant, as it affects the field distribution and propagation velocity.
-
Resonator size: The ring resonator should be large enough to minimize conductor and radiation losses, but small enough to avoid higher-order modes that complicate the response.
-
Frequency range: The measurement frequency range should be chosen to include multiple resonant modes while avoiding high-order modes and other spurious resonances.
By carefully designing the resonator, accurately fabricating it, and properly interpreting the measured results, the substrate dielectric constant can typically be determined with an accuracy of better than ±2%.
FAQ
What is the dielectric constant and why is it important?
The dielectric constant, also known as the relative permittivity, is a measure of a material’s ability to store electric energy in an electric field. In PCB substrates, the dielectric constant determines the speed of propagation of signals, the characteristic impedance of transmission lines, and the wavelength at a given frequency. Accurate knowledge of the dielectric constant is critical for designing circuits with controlled impedance, proper matching, and predictable frequency response.
How does the microstrip ring resonator method work?
The microstrip ring resonator method works by measuring the resonant frequencies of a ring of microstrip transmission line fabricated on the substrate to be characterized. At resonance, the circumference of the ring is an integer multiple of the guided wavelength, which depends on the effective dielectric constant of the microstrip line. By measuring the resonant frequencies and knowing the ring dimensions, the effective dielectric constant and substrate dielectric constant can be calculated.
What are the advantages of the microstrip ring resonator method?
The microstrip ring resonator method has several advantages:
- It is a simple, low-cost method that can be performed with standard PCB fabrication and test equipment.
- It measures the dielectric constant at the frequencies of interest for microwave circuits.
- It accounts for the effect of the substrate surface roughness and the conductor thickness on the effective dielectric constant.
- It can measure anisotropic substrates by fabricating resonators with different orientations.
What are the limitations of the microstrip ring resonator method?
The main limitations of the microstrip ring resonator method are:
- It assumes a low-loss substrate and may not be accurate for high-loss materials.
- It measures the dielectric constant at discrete frequencies corresponding to the resonant modes, rather than providing a continuous frequency response.
- It requires careful design and fabrication of the resonator to ensure accurate results.
Are there other methods for measuring the dielectric constant of PCB substrates?
Yes, there are several other methods for measuring the dielectric constant of PCB substrates, including:
- Cavity perturbation method: A sample of the substrate is inserted into a resonant cavity, and the change in resonant frequency is used to calculate the dielectric constant.
- Parallel plate capacitor method: The substrate is sandwiched between two metal plates to form a capacitor, and the capacitance is measured to determine the dielectric constant.
- Free-space method: A sample of the substrate is placed between two antennas, and the transmission and reflection coefficients are measured to extract the dielectric constant.
Each method has its own advantages and limitations, and the choice of method depends on the frequency range, substrate properties, and available equipment.
Conclusion
The microstrip ring resonator method is a simple and effective way to determine the dielectric constant of microwave PCB substrates. By fabricating a ring resonator on the substrate and measuring its resonant frequencies, the effective dielectric constant and substrate dielectric constant can be calculated with good accuracy. This information is essential for designing microwave circuits with controlled impedance, proper matching, and predictable performance.
When using the microstrip ring resonator method, it is important to carefully design the resonator, accurately fabricate it, and properly interpret the measured results. Factors such as substrate thickness, line width, copper thickness, resonator size, and frequency range can all affect the accuracy of the measurement.
By following the procedure outlined in this article and being aware of the potential sources of error, designers and engineers can confidently measure the dielectric constant of their PCB substrates and use this information to optimize their microwave circuit designs.
No responses yet